ScalperBigCat-AlpariUK-Demo (Od forex_trader_6565)
Uživatel odstranil tento systém.
ScalperBigCat-AlpariUK-Demo diskuse
Členem od Feb 16, 2010
1332 příspěvků
Mar 08, 2010 at 15:17
What I wanna say is that your EA doesn't seem bad at all at first look but it's just overpriced. I know how hard it is to create a winning EA but you have to realise every product should be priced according to its quality and potential which in your case are just AVERAGE.
"In trading, winning is frequently a question of luck, but losing is always a matter of skill."
forex_trader_6565
Členem od Feb 03, 2010
40 příspěvků
Mar 08, 2010 at 15:38
Forexma,, I have posted earlier that anyone who can submit a name of an EA being sold out there that is as stable as mine with low Drawdown would get a free copy of my EA. And My word still Stands. You're saying that its an Average EA, and all I am asking for is to prove it!
MM is the most important, when my EA enters a trade with a tight stoploss on 12 lots, is the same as entering 3 lots with Triple the stoploss, except that the Triple stoploss would expose more risk in my EA strategy.
I think the 1K price tag is way way too low for what I believe is the most stable EA on the Market.
If you 'Believe' that the pips gain is more important than money management, and you have a strategy that proof your standing point, then I suggest you start by posting your results on myfxbook to carry on with the debate.
MM is the most important, when my EA enters a trade with a tight stoploss on 12 lots, is the same as entering 3 lots with Triple the stoploss, except that the Triple stoploss would expose more risk in my EA strategy.
I think the 1K price tag is way way too low for what I believe is the most stable EA on the Market.
If you 'Believe' that the pips gain is more important than money management, and you have a strategy that proof your standing point, then I suggest you start by posting your results on myfxbook to carry on with the debate.
Členem od Feb 16, 2010
1332 příspěvků
Mar 08, 2010 at 16:12
ARE YOU SURE YOU'RE READY TO GIVE ME YOUR EA FOR FREE IF I SHOW YOU MORE PROFITABLE EA FOR SALE???
PLEASE BE SURE WHAT'RE YOU GONNA ANSWER BECAUSE EVERYBODY HERE WILL BE WHITNESS.
PLEASE BE SURE WHAT'RE YOU GONNA ANSWER BECAUSE EVERYBODY HERE WILL BE WHITNESS.
"In trading, winning is frequently a question of luck, but losing is always a matter of skill."
forex_trader_6565
Členem od Feb 03, 2010
40 příspěvků
Mar 08, 2010 at 16:19
Yes, absolutely 100% sure, and will thank you for it, the EA must be sold (Licensed), and not subscribed for. The Results must be posted on a third party tracking website with the trade History being published. If results are not posted on a third party website, then 99% they have been Either Re-set or Fabricated... Or Both :)
Please post the name of the EA, and consider your copy has been payed for. With a big 'thank you' from me.
Please post the name of the EA, and consider your copy has been payed for. With a big 'thank you' from me.
forex_trader_6565
Členem od Feb 03, 2010
40 příspěvků
Mar 08, 2010 at 16:27
also, must add that results has to be on live account,
Forgot to mention that you will recieve all future updates, and be treated as one of our own clients.
Please post the name so I can welcome you in the house :)
Forgot to mention that you will recieve all future updates, and be treated as one of our own clients.
Please post the name so I can welcome you in the house :)
Členem od Mar 07, 2010
257 příspěvků
Mar 08, 2010 at 17:09
(Upravené Mar 08, 2010 at 17:09)
so which broker would you recommend for $5k for USA residents ?
is the EA configurable ? Does it place trades for all those multiple currencies (can certain currencies be excluded in configuration) ?
Does it allow placing a definite SL or is it a 'mental' SL ?
Can it detect widening spread before entering the trade (news releases usually do that)?
is the EA configurable ? Does it place trades for all those multiple currencies (can certain currencies be excluded in configuration) ?
Does it allow placing a definite SL or is it a 'mental' SL ?
Can it detect widening spread before entering the trade (news releases usually do that)?
forex_trader_6565
Členem od Feb 03, 2010
40 příspěvků
Mar 08, 2010 at 17:26
Hello duzyfx,
so which broker would you recommend for $5k for USA residents ?
>As far as I can remember in my last research, US residence can open an account with FXPro.com... Please correct me if I am wrong.
is the EA configurable ?
>>Yes, but we advise that you stick with the configuration we design for your broker.
Does it place trades for all those multiple currencies (can certain currencies be excluded in configuration) ?
>>> Yes, deppending on Market conditions and if our money Manager would allow it.
Does it allow placing a definite SL or is it a 'mental' SL ?
>>>> No, we have placed an enternal stoploss... 'Mental' if you want to call it. and defined in the trading rules, so the EA does not wait till it gets hit of trade risk goes up.
Can it detect widening spread before entering the trade (news releases usually do that)?
>>>>> Yes, and that is very important tool... there is not much news release during it's trading period. But some brokes would just widen their pipspread, and our software is always prepared.
so which broker would you recommend for $5k for USA residents ?
>As far as I can remember in my last research, US residence can open an account with FXPro.com... Please correct me if I am wrong.
is the EA configurable ?
>>Yes, but we advise that you stick with the configuration we design for your broker.
Does it place trades for all those multiple currencies (can certain currencies be excluded in configuration) ?
>>> Yes, deppending on Market conditions and if our money Manager would allow it.
Does it allow placing a definite SL or is it a 'mental' SL ?
>>>> No, we have placed an enternal stoploss... 'Mental' if you want to call it. and defined in the trading rules, so the EA does not wait till it gets hit of trade risk goes up.
Can it detect widening spread before entering the trade (news releases usually do that)?
>>>>> Yes, and that is very important tool... there is not much news release during it's trading period. But some brokes would just widen their pipspread, and our software is always prepared.
Členem od Feb 16, 2010
1332 příspěvků
Mar 08, 2010 at 17:59
I cannot show you real account results but I can show you live demo forward test in few days, have to generate it first. Is that fine for you?
"In trading, winning is frequently a question of luck, but losing is always a matter of skill."
forex_trader_6565
Členem od Feb 03, 2010
40 příspěvků
Mar 08, 2010 at 18:05
If the EA is so good then why you still have not had it running live yet?!
No Demo is not enough,
Cheers,
No Demo is not enough,
Cheers,
Členem od Mar 07, 2010
60 příspěvků
Mar 08, 2010 at 18:11
nbakir posted:
If the EA is so good then why you still have not had it running live yet?!
No Demo is not enough,
Cheers,
Can i ask why demo is not enogh? (since the account you showing here is also a demo😕)
aaa
Členem od Feb 16, 2010
1332 příspěvků
Mar 08, 2010 at 18:17
(Upravené Mar 08, 2010 at 18:27)
With take profit sometimes more than 100 pips do you think demo result will be different from real account results? It is not a scalper so demo and real should be 95 equal IMHO.
"In trading, winning is frequently a question of luck, but losing is always a matter of skill."
Členem od Feb 16, 2010
1332 příspěvků
Mar 08, 2010 at 18:26
I'm just gonna give you a hint:
9 trading days = 41 trades = 522 pips
9 trading days = 41 trades = 522 pips
"In trading, winning is frequently a question of luck, but losing is always a matter of skill."
forex_trader_6565
Členem od Feb 03, 2010
40 příspěvků
Mar 08, 2010 at 18:32
does it trade GbpUsd and UsdJpy?
Yes I agree, Demo in that Case should be similar to live if the EA does not scalp.
But still need a one month forward test results, and I think I know what the EA is.
What is the stoploss it uses? and does it always target that 100 pips?
Yes I agree, Demo in that Case should be similar to live if the EA does not scalp.
But still need a one month forward test results, and I think I know what the EA is.
What is the stoploss it uses? and does it always target that 100 pips?
Členem od Aug 20, 2009
266 příspěvků
Mar 08, 2010 at 18:38
forexma,
How about ditching the hints and putting the system up here on a real account. Time to put your money where your mouth is.
How about ditching the hints and putting the system up here on a real account. Time to put your money where your mouth is.
Wealth Creation Through Technology
Členem od Feb 16, 2010
1332 příspěvků
Mar 08, 2010 at 18:43
Noordeen,
Please don't get me wrong. I like you, you seem like a honest guy. Probably your EA is good as well. I'm not trying to nag at you. I just don't like the way you're promoting your EA as the BEST commercial EA on the market.
I just wanna point your attention to the fact that there are and allways will be people smarter than us who are capable of creating excellent EA's. The EA I'm talking about is one of those excellent EA's which outperform every single EA out there, and I've seen enough. Enjoy your EA, I know how much efforts it costs to create a winning EA but just don't be so sure it's the best one and perfect. I personally trade with my private EA which is less profitable than yours but I'm happy with the results because I trust it, I know how it works, it has survived blizzards and storms and although it has suffered severe losses sometimes I know it's a good one and will recover. I have trading hostory with my EA for more than 18 months, it's not the best but it's it's good, it's mine.
Wish you luck!
Please don't get me wrong. I like you, you seem like a honest guy. Probably your EA is good as well. I'm not trying to nag at you. I just don't like the way you're promoting your EA as the BEST commercial EA on the market.
I just wanna point your attention to the fact that there are and allways will be people smarter than us who are capable of creating excellent EA's. The EA I'm talking about is one of those excellent EA's which outperform every single EA out there, and I've seen enough. Enjoy your EA, I know how much efforts it costs to create a winning EA but just don't be so sure it's the best one and perfect. I personally trade with my private EA which is less profitable than yours but I'm happy with the results because I trust it, I know how it works, it has survived blizzards and storms and although it has suffered severe losses sometimes I know it's a good one and will recover. I have trading hostory with my EA for more than 18 months, it's not the best but it's it's good, it's mine.
Wish you luck!
"In trading, winning is frequently a question of luck, but losing is always a matter of skill."
Členem od Feb 16, 2010
1332 příspěvků
Mar 08, 2010 at 18:50
(Upravené Mar 08, 2010 at 18:54)
compuforexpamm posted:That's something I could not do just because I don't have that system, its price is well over my financial possibilities at least for now. I just requested from the developer to start a forward test for me beginning from tomorrow.
forexma,
How about ditching the hints and putting the system up here on a real account. Time to put your money where your mouth is.
It trades eur/usd only with RR ~1:2
"In trading, winning is frequently a question of luck, but losing is always a matter of skill."
Členem od Feb 16, 2010
1332 příspěvků
Mar 09, 2010 at 09:05
Noordeen,
It seems that your super stable EA had terrible trading session tonight: it lost 198,8 pips on the FxPro live account resulting in 38,47% loss from the previous balance.
That is what I meant when I said trading history is too short to judge if the EA's good or bad. I'm sorry about the loss and would like to assure you that my criticism's only intention is to wake you up from your dream. I don't wanna laugh on other people's failure. I really enjoy seeing winning strategies, EA's and happy people. Your EA could still be profitable enough but you have to realise that you cannot be so confident about it.
BTW, I started the monitoring of the account trading the EA I mentioned yesterday, take a look at it here:
https://www.myfxbook.com/members/forexma/super-robot/21004
It seems that your super stable EA had terrible trading session tonight: it lost 198,8 pips on the FxPro live account resulting in 38,47% loss from the previous balance.
That is what I meant when I said trading history is too short to judge if the EA's good or bad. I'm sorry about the loss and would like to assure you that my criticism's only intention is to wake you up from your dream. I don't wanna laugh on other people's failure. I really enjoy seeing winning strategies, EA's and happy people. Your EA could still be profitable enough but you have to realise that you cannot be so confident about it.
BTW, I started the monitoring of the account trading the EA I mentioned yesterday, take a look at it here:
https://www.myfxbook.com/members/forexma/super-robot/21004
"In trading, winning is frequently a question of luck, but losing is always a matter of skill."
forex_trader_6565
Členem od Feb 03, 2010
40 příspěvků
Mar 09, 2010 at 09:30
Check it out every two weeks,, it will recover slowly
forex_trader_7
Členem od Aug 01, 2009
941 příspěvků
Mar 09, 2010 at 10:19
(Upravené Mar 09, 2010 at 10:24)
Never mind.
Členem od Sep 04, 2009
879 příspěvků
Mar 11, 2010 at 12:53
forexma posted:
Noordeen,
It seems that your super stable EA had terrible trading session tonight: it lost 198,8 pips on the FxPro live account resulting in 38,47% loss from the previous balance.
That is what I meant when I said trading history is too short to judge if the EA's good or bad. I'm sorry about the loss and would like to assure you that my criticism's only intention is to wake you up from your dream. I don't wanna laugh on other people's failure. I really enjoy seeing winning strategies, EA's and happy people. Your EA could still be profitable enough but you have to realise that you cannot be so confident about it.
BTW, I started the monitoring of the account trading the EA I mentioned yesterday, take a look at it here:
https://www.myfxbook.com/members/forexma/super-robot/21004
Whats up with the 'super robot'? Last time i saw it public it was in deep sh$t....
