EA Test Perbincangan

traktorista posted:
i try to follow them 3000eur equity blow aacount in less then 24hours......they openend 4.5 lots in total position they try AVERAGE pure amateur

@traktorista
in name of mighty Zetor :) I trust you

numbers speak for itself
https://www.signalstart.com/analysis/elite/13563

can you give better starts than this?

Aeries,

I hope you make a lot of money with this signal, really.

However I am with Ozzie. Traders that manipulate their results by cheating with deposit/withdrawals are simply not honest. I have seen so many times people in good faith suffering huge losses because of fraud. Fraud in everywhere in Forex and, believe me, I am not paranoid.

A trader that cheats one time will do it twice. I never trust people that are not 100% transparent. That's my rule.

Having said that, if this account is still there in six months. I will be happy to invest.

Regards.

tell me, is it cheating if you withdraw your money? if i make 100%, i will surely withdraw
Look at the ABS gain in myfxbook, you will know the gain based on original deposit

in forex, what matters is you make money. we dont care how.
as long as it is a reputable broker, verified live.

i will be happy to see my account 6 months from now. i hope that signal still be on top
so i already make profit that time :)

OK

I must admit I was really curious about this system and therefore I decided to subscribe the signal and see what happens.

My conclusion is that is not strictly a scam but quite a smart system set up by his author. Also I believe it is an extremely risky system for anyone subscribing to the signal. Let me add that I have nothing against the author of the signal or any of the investors using it. But I would like to share my conclusions for those interested.

Three things called strongly my attention at the beginning. First, the system has a 100% trades closed on profit. Second, the system has a carried equity of 800%+. Third, the trades have no SL..

This morning when I subscribed to the signal the system opened automatically 8 trades NZDUSD. Obviously these were the only trades that could be opened because they were the only ones at loss at that time. Signalstar can not open the trades with floating positive equity because this would put the subscriber in a worst position that the master trader and this is not allowed by the system. Opening only negative trades, per definition,will put always the subscriber in better position than the trader. If you do not understand vey well this point please read it again because this is exactly the reason why the system is extraordinarily risky.

So, I was sitting with 8 USDNZD trades opened without SL (it was 1.21 lots on a 7000 USD balance account). And here is when it comes the first element of my analysis, this is that the system has a 100% trades closed in profit, in other words, if my trades would turn in red ( and they were in red approx 2%), THEY WILL WILL NEVER BE CLOSED until they will turn back in profit disregard of how big my level of DD will be. Why?, first, because the trader account had other NZDUSD trades in green that covered several times the loss ( unfortunately not my case for the reason explained before) and, second, because the trader does not care at all having a 800%+ floating equity.

In other words, my account might go bankrupt seven times and there would be no effect on the signal statistics.

And this is the fact, the owner of the account has no problem carrying losing trades for a long, very long time because he has the buffer of his positive equity. However the subscriber is absolutely opened to huge DD specially considering the amount of trades opened in relation with the balance of the subscriber account.

Sure, but, some will say, he is a great trader and this will never happen. Well Ok, may be. But not really. Check the equity of the signal. This is the only element you have to pay attention here!!. In one month and a half it has four drastic reductions. Any of them would put your account at a big risk. Four times in a month and a half. Make yourself the calculation.

These are facts, now the question is whether this has been made on purpose by the trader to attract subscribers to a system that is basically a killing machine. I leave this to you but answer only this question. If you had such a magic system, would you invest only 100 USD?. Also, would you sell the signal at all or you would spend your time collecting Ferraris.

Answer. yourself.

Regards.

Pablo51 posted:
OK

I must admit I was really curious about this system and therefore I decided to subscribe the signal and see what happens.

My conclusion is that is not strictly a scam but quite a smart system set up by his author. Also I believe it is an extremely risky system for anyone subscribing to the signal. Let me add that I have nothing against the author of the signal or any of the investors using it. But I would like to share my conclusions for those interested.

Three things called strongly my attention at the beginning. First, the system has a 100% trades closed on profit. Second, the system has a carried equity of 800%+. Third, the trades have no SL..

This morning when I subscribed to the signal the system opened automatically 8 trades NZDUSD. Obviously these were the only trades that could be opened because they were the only ones at loss at that time. Signalstar can not open the trades with floating positive equity because this would put the subscriber in a worst position that the master trader and this is not allowed by the system. Opening only negative trades, per definition,will put always the subscriber in better position than the trader. If you do not understand vey well this point please read it again because this is exactly the reason why the system is extraordinarily risky.

So, I was sitting with 8 USDNZD trades opened without SL (it was 1.21 lots on a 7000 USD balance account). And here is when it comes the first element of my analysis, this is that the system has a 100% trades closed in profit, in other words, if my trades would turn in red ( and they were in red approx 2%), THEY WILL WILL NEVER BE CLOSED until they will turn back in profit disregard of how big my level of DD will be. Why?, first, because the trader account had other NZDUSD trades in green that covered several times the loss ( unfortunately not my case for the reason explained before) and, second, because the trader does not care at all having a 800%+ floating equity.

In other words, my account might go bankrupt seven times and there would be no effect on the signal statistics.

And this is the fact, the owner of the account has no problem carrying losing trades for a long, very long time because he has the buffer of his positive equity. However the subscriber is absolutely opened to huge DD specially considering the amount of trades opened in relation with the balance of the subscriber account.

Sure, but, some will say, he is a great trader and this will never happen. Well Ok, may be. But not really. Check the equity of the signal. This is the only element you have to pay attention here!!. In one month and a half it has four drastic reductions. Any of them would put your account at a big risk. Four times in a month and a half. Make yourself the calculation.

These are facts, now the question is whether this has been made on purpose by the trader to attract subscribers to a system that is basically a killing machine. I leave this to you but answer only this question. If you had such a magic system, would you invest only 100 USD?. Also, would you sell the signal at all or you would spend your time collecting Ferraris.

Answer. yourself.

Regards.

@Pablo51
Thank you for analyses. It seems this system is good just for the owner not for anyone else.

Pablo51 posted:
OK

I must admit I was really curious about this system and therefore I decided to subscribe the signal and see what happens.

My conclusion is that is not strictly a scam but quite a smart system set up by his author. Also I believe it is an extremely risky system for anyone subscribing to the signal. Let me add that I have nothing against the author of the signal or any of the investors using it. But I would like to share my conclusions for those interested.

Three things called strongly my attention at the beginning. First, the system has a 100% trades closed on profit. Second, the system has a carried equity of 800%+. Third, the trades have no SL..

This morning when I subscribed to the signal the system opened automatically 8 trades NZDUSD. Obviously these were the only trades that could be opened because they were the only ones at loss at that time. Signalstar can not open the trades with floating positive equity because this would put the subscriber in a worst position that the master trader and this is not allowed by the system. Opening only negative trades, per definition,will put always the subscriber in better position than the trader. If you do not understand vey well this point please read it again because this is exactly the reason why the system is extraordinarily risky.

So, I was sitting with 8 USDNZD trades opened without SL (it was 1.21 lots on a 7000 USD balance account). And here is when it comes the first element of my analysis, this is that the system has a 100% trades closed in profit, in other words, if my trades would turn in red ( and they were in red approx 2%), THEY WILL WILL NEVER BE CLOSED until they will turn back in profit disregard of how big my level of DD will be. Why?, first, because the trader account had other NZDUSD trades in green that covered several times the loss ( unfortunately not my case for the reason explained before) and, second, because the trader does not care at all having a 800%+ floating equity.

In other words, my account might go bankrupt seven times and there would be no effect on the signal statistics.

And this is the fact, the owner of the account has no problem carrying losing trades for a long, very long time because he has the buffer of his positive equity. However the subscriber is absolutely opened to huge DD specially considering the amount of trades opened in relation with the balance of the subscriber account.

Sure, but, some will say, he is a great trader and this will never happen. Well Ok, may be. But not really. Check the equity of the signal. This is the only element you have to pay attention here!!. In one month and a half it has four drastic reductions. Any of them would put your account at a big risk. Four times in a month and a half. Make yourself the calculation.

These are facts, now the question is whether this has been made on purpose by the trader to attract subscribers to a system that is basically a killing machine. I leave this to you but answer only this question. If you had such a magic system, would you invest only 100 USD?. Also, would you sell the signal at all or you would spend your time collecting Ferraris.

Answer. yourself.

Regards.

And today ALL the NZD trades closed in profit. So im sure you made profit


Now all trades are positive, anyone may subscribe because new trades opened will start negative
thus putting the subscriber in a better place like you said :)

Cheers to the author and spectacular performance

THIS IS THE BEST I'VE SEEN SO FAR!
I cant believe it is available for subscribe.
I contacted author but does not respond, maybe too busy....

NOW IS GOOD TIME SO SUBSCRIBE. All trades are positive
No time sitting around and wait others like Aeries said
I want a slice of pie. I hope author will not increase the price!


I WILL UPDATE EVERYTIME!!!!

babysitter posted:
THIS IS THE BEST I'VE SEEN SO FAR!
I cant believe it is available for subscribe.
I contacted author but does not respond, maybe too busy....

NOW IS GOOD TIME SO SUBSCRIBE. All trades are positive
No time sitting around and wait others like Aeries said
I want a slice of pie. I hope author will not increase the price!


I WILL UPDATE EVERYTIME!!!!

price already increased mate. I have subscribed too.

Lets see the new trades in action

Well, I would avoid any strategy showing NOT A SINGLE LOSING TRADE whatsoever, as such strategies obviously do not have a stop loss or a way to deal with the occasional bad trades, expect for the often used ''Hope & Pray'' which has not been statistically validated as an effective trading method.

These STOPLESS (not ''topless'' 😄) strategies can be 'lucky' for a while (even for up to 6-8 months), but eventually they all meet their unavoidable faith, i.e. the dreaded margin call.

Of course, the other option is that someone has invented the 'Holy Grail' of Forex and he is selling it on SignalStart for ''peanuts'...

wildy posted:
Damn, aweseme trader!
My account 1st day, account up by 15%!!!!

And open position still profit.

It is quite strange,

in this topic every user who wrote it is working and producing gains
none of these share any account
This user doesn't share any systems currently

Usually if you have sooo profitable account you are dying to share it with others...

long was opened today.

wildy posted:
Damn, aweseme trader!
My account 1st day, account up by 15%!!!!

And open position still profit.

:)

aeries posted:
long was opened today.

This user doesn't share any systems currently.

All these guys in this topic who created new accounts recently without single comment or single account
just posting positive review of this system.
Sounds like fake to me.

togr posted:

aeries posted:
long was opened today.

This user doesn't share any systems currently.

All these guys in this topic who created new accounts recently without single comment or single account
just posting positive review of this system.
Sounds like fake to me.

Yes it is true. Next manipulation of deposit with this account Gatex for 1 days +12,587% Gain!!!

I write to support signalstart for change the rules.

PS: Old message from Chris support: Our dev team is making changes and improving the ranking formula (Still no change)

wildy posted:
Damn, aweseme trader!
My account 1st day, account up by 15%!!!!

And open position still profit.

You obviously mean your equity not your balance.

Balance is 0.13% up for the week and as far as I know you can not withdraw your equity.

If you look at the real numbers here, you take the profit of $1164 and divide it by the deposit of $101, and you get an absolute gain of +1152% ROI for 1.5 months of trading with no losing trades. I always ignore the Gain number even here on My Fx Book because its not a realistic number.

The bottom line here, is that this guy makes money either way you want to look at the results. Yes its very weird that he kept with drawing all of his profits, except for $1.00 for the first few days, but that was his choice. With Signal Start you can set your risk like maximum number of open trades, lot size etc to suite your risk style.

Jarora posted:

togr posted:

aeries posted:
long was opened today.

This user doesn't share any systems currently.

All these guys in this topic who created new accounts recently without single comment or single account
just posting positive review of this system.
Sounds like fake to me.

Yes it is true. Next manipulation of deposit with this account Gatex for 1 days +12,587% Gain!!!

I write to support signalstart for change the rules.

PS: Old message from Chris support: Our dev team is making changes and improving the ranking formula (Still no change)

Hi all. Now I see fix manipulation of deposit for new all account. Speculators ended.

Jarora posted:

Jarora posted:

togr posted:

aeries posted:
long was opened today.

This user doesn't share any systems currently.

All these guys in this topic who created new accounts recently without single comment or single account
just posting positive review of this system.
Sounds like fake to me.

Yes it is true. Next manipulation of deposit with this account Gatex for 1 days +12,587% Gain!!!

I write to support signalstart for change the rules.

PS: Old message from Chris support: Our dev team is making changes and improving the ranking formula (Still no change)

Hi all. Now I see fix manipulation of deposit for new all account. Speculators ended.

And voila
You Are Here : Home / Community / Trading Systems / EA Test
EA Test (by fxquickroute) Quick Stats
The user has deleted this system.