James Harrison (による MIA491)
| 増加 : | -51.04% |
| ドローダウン | 94.97% |
| ピップス: | 47857.0 |
| 取引 | 348 |
| 勝利: |
|
| 負け: |
|
| タイプ: | リアル |
| レバレッジ: | 1:100 |
| 取引: | 手動 |
James Harrison 討論
Sep 02, 2018 at 06:37
fxbreaker posted:good to find out.. hopefully fintech can take a look to check also.. i encounter similar issue in.ic market where by the trade execute at diff prices as trade or set by ea, what they explain is due to slipage in market and price capture at non expexted point... il expect fintech can take action to investigate also...LongVision posted:AxeTrader posted:Just share your trading results in myfxbook in place of defending this trading system that will be more credible than your comment.fxbreaker posted:this is interesting something new now.. you qoute that odin and fintech is one group ? and the user able to access to server ? can we prove that ? im one of the users from fintech that copy the trade from James, as far as im concern is the profit and consistency.. i have randomly counter check the trade in fintech vs other broker like IC market do not found the issue.. to be fair to every one.. please do not accuse any party if do not have any prove ...LongVision posted:chinchano_1984 posted:This only create doubt about this trading system why he is only using shady and offshore brokers which has no safety of fund and questionable execution quality. Why can't he just open MAM account with regulated and known broker?
why fintech? i check your system your another system 'James Harrison' and appear the broker 'Odin Capital', why?
Because odin and fintechfx are their (MIA/James Harisson) own broker, they are all in one group.
with you have access to MT4 Server, you can create trade like that (80% win),
and even myfxbook will flag the trading as verified, because myfxbook really connect to their real MT4 server.
They will not dare to use real strict regulated broker
Just trading result is quite difficult to find the fake trading, because each broker maybe have slight difference in price / candle
btw this is sample of fake trading in FintechFX:
When sell price (bid) is out of range the candle 😀
I'm sure after this the boss in Mia-fintech will smack the head of 'James Harrison' create this trade ... maybe after this they will try to alter all abnormal trade, either change the open-close price, or even change the candle range.
Sep 02, 2018 at 14:58
AxeTrader posted:
[good to find out.. hopefully fintech can take a look to check also.. i encounter similar issue in.ic market where by the trade execute at diff prices as trade or set by ea, what they explain is due to slipage in market and price capture at non expexted point... il expect fintech can take action to investigate also...
it's a different case
Slippage refers to the difference between the expected price of a trade and the price at which the trade is actually executed. Slippage often occurs during periods of higher volatility when market orders are used
(https://www.investopedia.com/terms/s/slippage.asp)
Even if you experience slippage (different from EA price / SL / TP that you have set), the bid price STILL ON THE CANDLE chart, because it's market execution price, all bid execution should be on the candle range.
But MIA-FintechFX suspected to do 'manual back-door entry' trading to their mt4 server, just before they publish the result to MIA member, so this impossible execution price often occurs,
Just try observe yourself on your FintechFX MT4 .. example on Aug 13 - 17 period .. I found 3 impossible price out of 5 trades that weeks, please do owncheck, this error occurs > 30% of their trading.
Please awake, you have been fooled by fake licenses, it's already enough reason to quit, MIA-FintechFX is just another scam, after they gather more money from JHE and deposit bonus program from member, they will try to find 'right excuse' to lost all of your money, and will throw all fault to FintechFX, maybe they will say suddenly 'know the truth' that FintechFX have FAKE NFA and ASIC Licenses, but they will say MIA do not hold the money, all the money on FintechFX, and FintechFX suddenly disappeared,
... well it's just one of the 'right excuse' of their scam scenario.
Aug 07, 2014からメンバー
61 投稿
Sep 03, 2018 at 07:00
then is is true ?
chinchano_1984@
Sep 03, 2018 at 07:09
fxbreaker posted:AxeTrader posted:
[good to find out.. hopefully fintech can take a look to check also.. i encounter similar issue in.ic market where by the trade execute at diff prices as trade or set by ea, what they explain is due to slipage in market and price capture at non expexted point... il expect fintech can take action to investigate also...
it's a different case
Slippage refers to the difference between the expected price of a trade and the price at which the trade is actually executed. Slippage often occurs during periods of higher volatility when market orders are used
(https://www.investopedia.com/terms/s/slippage.asp)
Even if you experience slippage (different from EA price / SL / TP that you have set), the bid price STILL ON THE CANDLE chart, because it's market execution price, all bid execution should be on the candle range.
But MIA-FintechFX suspected to do 'manual back-door entry' trading to their mt4 server, just before they publish the result to MIA member, so this impossible execution price often occurs,
Just try observe yourself on your FintechFX MT4 .. example on Aug 13 - 17 period .. I found 3 impossible price out of 5 trades that weeks, please do owncheck, this error occurs > 30% of their trading.
Please awake, you have been fooled by fake licenses, it's already enough reason to quit, MIA-FintechFX is just another scam, after they gather more money from JHE and deposit bonus program from member, they will try to find 'right excuse' to lost all of your money, and will throw all fault to FintechFX, maybe they will say suddenly 'know the truth' that FintechFX have FAKE NFA and ASIC Licenses, but they will say MIA do not hold the money, all the money on FintechFX, and FintechFX suddenly disappeared,
... well it's just one of the 'right excuse' of their scam scenario.
good job fxbreaker to catch few point! if it is too abnormal we need to report for investigate, i have reported these to fintech, some of you can also report to open the case, let's see what they say is consistent across...
Sep 03, 2018 at 11:22
AxeTrader posted:
good job fxbreaker to catch few point! if it is too abnormal we need to report for investigate, i have reported these to fintech, some of you can also report to open the case, let's see what they say is consistent across...
for your fund safety, if you still hope that MIA is not scam, just try to withdraw almost all your fund, and just left behind $1000 on FintechFX Investment Point as minimal mandatory amount for MIA member.
this way if you already have a large network in MIA, you will still got Group Profit bonus / Unilevel profit bonus / Leadership bonus that usually much bigger than Personal Profit Sharing.
if your withdrawal amount is huge > 20K, just hope that your money will be really transferred, if after 5-7 working days the money is not arrived then it's a sign they start collapsing.
this way you will play safe .. even if they go scam .. I think you already got your ROI,
also you better inform your group members about this scam possibility, so your relation and friends is not unrepairable.
Apr 06, 2018からメンバー
254 投稿
Sep 04, 2018 at 11:00
(編集済みのSep 04, 2018 at 11:05)
ftr4ders posted:LongVision posted:chinchano_1984 posted:This only create doubt about this trading system why he is only using shady and offshore brokers which has no safety of fund and questionable execution quality. Why can't he just open MAM account with regulated and known broker?
why fintech? i check your system your another system 'James Harrison' and appear the broker 'Odin Capital', why?
Have you in each successful topic - doubts. This is his business and the right to use offshore brokers, for this there can be many reasons that you does not understand
He can use any offshore broker there is no problem but the problem here This system owner encouraging his subscribers to deposit money with a shady and offshore broker only so there is no safety of fund for subscribers.
The market will trade through it’s path of least resistance .
Apr 06, 2018からメンバー
254 投稿
Sep 04, 2018 at 11:00
ftr4ders posted:LongVision posted:chinchano_1984 posted:This only create doubt about this trading system why he is only using shady and offshore brokers which has no safety of fund and questionable execution quality. Why can't he just open MAM account with regulated and known broker?
why fintech? i check your system your another system 'James Harrison' and appear the broker 'Odin Capital', why?
Have you in each successful topic - doubts. This is his business and the right to use offshore brokers, for this there can be many reasons that you does not understand
Lol User ftr4ders wasnt found. This explains everything.
https://www.myfxbook.com/members/ftr4ders
The market will trade through it’s path of least resistance .
Aug 07, 2014からメンバー
61 投稿
Sep 04, 2018 at 12:34
if compare the entries with another mt4 for other broker...... then the price not real ??? (my english is bad sorry)
chinchano_1984@
Aug 07, 2014からメンバー
61 投稿
Sep 04, 2018 at 13:55
付属品:
chinchano_1984@
Sep 04, 2018 at 13:56
chinchano_1984 posted:if compare the price in IC market is 1177.82 , the trade or execute price is okay.. just the price on the close high/low on their MT4 have some gap need them to check..
if compare the entries with another mt4 for other broker...... then the price not real ??? (my english is bad sorry)
Aug 07, 2014からメンバー
61 投稿
Sep 04, 2018 at 13:56
exist many accounts in myfxbook following the mia491, some with visible history
chinchano_1984@
Aug 07, 2014からメンバー
61 投稿
Sep 04, 2018 at 15:00
the prices in all the mt4 are always different due to the issue of the spread.
An example how rare and fraudulent is a candle is green in any broker but in fintech the candle is red
An example how rare and fraudulent is a candle is green in any broker but in fintech the candle is red
chinchano_1984@
Sep 05, 2018 at 10:29
chinchano_1984 posted:
the prices in all the mt4 are always different due to the issue of the spread.
An example how rare and fraudulent is a candle is green in any broker but in fintech the candle is red
Read my post before, you must understand different between spread price, and fake trading price (out of candle)
fxbreaker posted:
You can try open your MT4 trader, you should find many of “SELL” point are out of chart / candle (for buy op -> see the end of trade/sell, for sell op -> see the start of trade), sell point SHOULD NOT BE OUT OF CHART/CANDLE, buy point can be out of chart / candle because of spread.
Example :
2018.08.16 10:45:18 SELL XAU/USD at [b]1177.58[/b]
But the candle in M1 is : Open: 1177.39 High: 1177.50 Low: 1177.26 Close: 1177.26
Another example:
2018.08.03 12:17:33 BUY XAU/USD at 1207.94 sell at [b]1209.91 (2018.08.03 14:11:48)[/b]
M1 (2018.08.03 14:11) is : Open: 1209.23 High: 1209.89 Low: 1209.09 Close: 1209.87
You can try find many other impossible trade price, just check yourself.
also I didn't get what you mean with chart above ? what do you want to share, is it spread? yes spread on fintechfx occurs on ask/buy price (ask price = bid/sell + spread), and candle data on fintechfx is based on bid/sell price. so ALL bid price (can be start sell OR end of buy) should be on candle data, if not then it's indication of fake trading
Aug 07, 2014からメンバー
61 投稿
Sep 05, 2018 at 13:33
I AM NOT A CLIENT OF MIA
I would give you the reason as long as none of the prices were touched,
I would give you the reason as long as I do not see a profit between the buy or sell of the operations
but, I do not see any of that
the prices differ in each broker, throughout my life in trading in many brokers the prices are very different both in the bid and in the ask (regulated and unregulated brokers)
even in the same broker (regulated) strange things have happened to me, for example in a computer the price reaches the candle, but in another computer the price goes in a different location to the candle (same broker, same account, but different computer )
For my part I do not see anything suspicious, the only suspect is that they use an unknown broker for a good system (VERY RARE)
I would give you the reason as long as none of the prices were touched,
I would give you the reason as long as I do not see a profit between the buy or sell of the operations
but, I do not see any of that
the prices differ in each broker, throughout my life in trading in many brokers the prices are very different both in the bid and in the ask (regulated and unregulated brokers)
even in the same broker (regulated) strange things have happened to me, for example in a computer the price reaches the candle, but in another computer the price goes in a different location to the candle (same broker, same account, but different computer )
For my part I do not see anything suspicious, the only suspect is that they use an unknown broker for a good system (VERY RARE)
chinchano_1984@
Sep 06, 2018 at 07:29
chinchano_1984 posted:
-cut-
even in the same broker (regulated) strange things have happened to me, for example in a computer the price reaches the candle, but in another computer the price goes in a different location to the candle (same broker, same account, but different computer )
For my part I do not see anything suspicious, the only suspect is that they use an unknown broker for a good system (VERY RARE)
Maybe for that case (same broker, different data) there is issue in MT4 client/network delay so some computer missing 'ticks' from broker.
But MT4 data can be 'REFRESHED' so All missing / different data will be RE-DOWNLOADED from broker, just try this in your MT4 that have different chart data on SAME BROKER. Just Right-Click on chart and click refresh, then all different / missing data will be updated.
After you do the refresh, please inform us in this forum, if you STILL have 'Different Chart on SAME Broker'.
FYI, FintechFx fake trading suspects are based on 'refreshed data' from Server, so it is IMPOSSIBLE to have 'bid' price that not in the chart,
If that transaction occurs, the chart data should follow that transaction data, and that bid price will be the 'High' price on the candle.
付属品:
Aug 07, 2014からメンバー
61 投稿
Sep 06, 2018 at 12:48
But.... i am not newbie jejejeje
chinchano_1984@
Sep 07, 2018 at 05:31
chinchano_1984 posted:
But.... i am not newbie jejejeje
hahaha, my apologize m(_ _)m , it turns out you are trader master sifu .... 😉
and I see your trading performance is great,
and your real account is on IC Market ,
so your profile is much much more reliable than this James Harrison that trading on FintechFX :) :)
btw .. so I guess you should agree that 'Refreshed Data' from broker should give same chart in any computer right ..
Feb 23, 2017からメンバー
1 投稿
Sep 09, 2018 at 05:54
hi can i talk with you
Sep 12, 2018 at 07:11
braveh4rt posted:
Is it possible to do fake trade? since 2016 ?
how come some of you said its fake trade?
i wonder how it works if can do that, and i hear they have many clients already copy their open position since years ago.
Why Not Possible, when they also own the broker (FintechFX and Odin Capital)
myfxbook only retrieve trading history from server,
right now myfxbook is not verifying if the trading is genuine or faked. verified status only mean that the trading history data is really on broker server.
