StatArb Pro 250,000 USD 討論

yes seriously!
your equity curve is seriously fat and below the balance curve.

I am not going to play spy games here. which account which, which history data is correct or not.

I said I will wait and see.
I am not interested in history.
will see the future performance.

there should be some reasons that push you into the retail scam jungle and leaving big profitable Hedge funds ( or doing both ).
we will learn that also soon.

walker

PS : you should ıdentfy who is against who is wating to see and who is jumpers.
your first customers will be jumpers.
I am at the wait side.

statarbpro posted:

stevewalker posted:
you can shows pips with Loss in balance. this shows nothing. positive Pips + posıtıve Balance shows the profibility.

I will wait and see.

good luck.

walker

Seriously? Because a few pages ago you posted this:





Which clearly shows both 21,000+ pips and a 53% gain.

stevewalker posted:

there should be some reasons that push you into the retail scam jungle and leaving big profitable Hedge funds ( or doing both ).
we will learn that also soon.

walker

PS : you should ıdentfy who is against who is wating to see and who is jumpers.
your first customers will be jumpers.
I am at the wait side.

The reason I entered the retail 'scam jungle' as you called it, is because I believe it or not, genuinely care. How many other EA sellers put up their own name and face on their site? I'm proud to be associated with this product. And as far as the rest? I'll never quit trading for institutions. It seems that no one can believe that anyone would do anything for any other reason but to scam someone. This is just bizarre to me.

will wait and see

no more good luck!
- first you dont understand what it means
- you dont need it

walker

statarbpro posted:

stevewalker posted:

there should be some reasons that push you into the retail scam jungle and leaving big profitable Hedge funds ( or doing both ).
we will learn that also soon.

walker

PS : you should ıdentfy who is against who is wating to see and who is jumpers.
your first customers will be jumpers.
I am at the wait side.

The reason I entered the retail 'scam jungle' as you called it, is because I believe it or not, genuinely care. How many other EA sellers put up their own name and face on their site? I'm proud to be associated with this product. And as far as the rest? I'll never quit trading for institutions. It seems that no one can believe that anyone would do anything for any other reason but to scam someone. This is just bizarre to me.

@Walker, the equity is below but it is all about relativity - even though it falls below balance, it is still keeping the account profitable, so I would wait and see how it continues to build.

@TheCyclist - just relax and let the performance speak for itself. statarbpro answered all of your questions without hesitations so I do think this is a genuine trading system. Sometimes its hard to believe when you see someone has succeeded where you failed. I'm don't know for a fact if this is the case, but there is no point trying to flame this thread. Think for a second if you did believe the system is real and working and statarbpro is a genuine trader - would his answers be different? (hope you see my point here)

@statarbpro - this is definitely not an easy task to have your trading system analyzed publicly, but you're doing a great job. I do think you have a working system there and I'll be watching closely to see how it performs (no pressure! 😄)

statarbpro

can you please unlock the 'comments' of linked account

https://www.myfxbook.com/members/statarbpro/statarb-pro/357731

thanks in advance
walker

Well

50% ppl of this thread are ruined by life. So sketptikal that they criticize anythiing.
They will never make a move to pull themselves out of the losing circle. Sometime it is of more use to stop talking (mental can find thousands of excuses) either you wait. And see. Either you jump in, for 297$ its worth trying, as far as you dont buy hundreds of EA.

Get one. Get a VPS, forget about your trading with this account. Come back to check results month after.
And keep trading on your normal account. You'll see. Personnaly. I can buy it. I'm 90% sure its not a scam.
This guy answers all questions. he has not disappeared. And maybe ihe 'll be here month after (except if people keep being that skeptical)

Well in the end. Try it for yourself and see after. 300$ compared to what one can put at stake on his trading account for losing. It's quite a bit, but not much much.
So just quit the BS girl chatting, venture yourself trying it. And post a few month after results.


I have a nice, and real stories.
I guy put up an EA, for 300$ per month. There were like hundreds of EA to select, so it was one EA amongst other. Maybe doubted scam of course, because it exists.

Some tried it in 2008. The owner was trading it real. Or 'said' he was trading it real.
After 2 or 3 months. Everybody or so quited. Because they ve been whatching the trades going against them, as propretary might use personnalized strategy. They had maybe negative performances overall the three months.

Thus you could see comments of this EA, with only one star out of five rating : 'Very bad perfmance! Trade go against the trend blabla !!! Owner not carefull ! I do not recommand ! '
etc..

The owner account was in 2008 20 00O$ average.
Now it's nearly two millions. 2.000.000$

If thos users would have stayed in for this time they would be rich for life.
But They quited cause of fear and maybe -10% over 3 month whereas owner is pretty confident about his system. Maybe some are still struggling to make money on forex.
Any way some EA don't work. But Some do. If you chat that much over an EA you act like a girl.
Just be a man ask 1 or 2 questions. Make your opinion. Take it or not and shut up. Comment after. Anything else is waste of time. You wi ll never be able to know the truth by asking questions or being skeptikal on the internet. Just try it or go away.
And don't be a bitch. Let it run for months.
Im no winning trader. But i can make some profits. I'm developping my method. And if i manage to get where i want to be at.
High risk reward trades (1/2 - 1/4 1-8). A few losing. 80% winner. Simplicity.

I'll probably select a few trader to help them because i 'll remember when this was hard. And sell it fora few hundreds of bucks. Even if i do 1000£ a day on the forex.
Face it. Had you a winning system. Would you give it away for free. Or would you just put a small counterpart in $$. ? Nothing is free. Or you gotta be very good. Even though. I doubt something free is perceived with value.

getting very fast answers to posts
but this one still waiting for the 3rd time.

very fast about finding the ones that he thinks those works for him. he may also find the related ones to this post.


walker

stevewalker posted:
statarbpro

can you please unlock the 'comments' of linked account

https://www.myfxbook.com/members/statarbpro/statarb-pro/357731

thanks in advance
walker

James
you know better then me. remeber your posts about fat below balance.

systems equity below balance ( that much ) soon or late blow.

walker

James_Bond posted:
@Walker, the equity is below but it is all about relativity - even though it falls below balance, it is still keeping the account profitable, so I would wait and see how it continues to build.

@TheCyclist - just relax and let the performance speak for itself. statarbpro answered all of your questions without hesitations so I do think this is a genuine trading system. Sometimes its hard to believe when you see someone has succeeded where you failed. I'm don't know for a fact if this is the case, but there is no point trying to flame this thread. Think for a second if you did believe the system is real and working and statarbpro is a genuine trader - would his answers be different? (hope you see my point here)

@statarbpro - this is definitely not an easy task to have your trading system analyzed publicly, but you're doing a great job. I do think you have a working system there and I'll be watching closely to see how it performs (no pressure! 😄)

stevewalker posted:
getting very fast answers to posts
but this one still waiting for the 3rd time.

very fast about finding the ones that he thinks those works for him. he may also find the related ones to this post.


walker

stevewalker posted:
statarbpro

can you please unlock the 'comments' of linked account

https://www.myfxbook.com/members/statarbpro/statarb-pro/357731

thanks in advance
walker

It's Sunday morning and I'm relaxing on my balcony having some coffee, laptop in my lap, catching up on some support emails, so forgive me if I'm not as speedy as you require in responding to your posts.

Regarding your question. I know you've asked that my live account have the comments unlocked. The answer is now and will always be, no. Not that I have to justify it to anyone, but the deposits and withdrawals from the account have personal information in the comments, like bank account #s'. If I unlock the order comments, those will be viewable by everyone on myfxbook. I will not be unlocking those now, nor ever.

Regarding the other testing account you want unlocked, the answer again is no. A lot of my testing involves printing output from the EA into the comments. I'm not giving away the strategy. Sorry, so again no.

I don't see how the comments work to your advantage. What is they all said 'stevenwalker' in the comments? How would this help you anyway?

I will gladly listen to any other requests however.

or may be some trades handled manually

we wil see

walker

giving strategy with comments
giving bank information with comments

being funny with every post

go on

stevewalker posted:
giving strategy with comments
giving bank information with comments

being funny with every post

go on

Seriously? Your brokerage doesn't show the account # to which you made a withdrawal to? Like right there where the arrows are? Have you ever made a withdrawal?



Belief in my reasons is not a prerequisite for them being true. Case in point: you don't have to believe in gravity either, but step off the top of a building and it'll introduce itself.

stevewalker posted:
giving strategy with comments
giving bank information with comments

being funny with every post

go on

All that said, you have not explained WHY you want to see them so badly and what benefit that will give? Because you want to see them is not reason enough for me to divulge personal information for the world to see. Post your bank account numbers here. No? Well then me either!

I'm pretty sure what is going on here is you're the quintessential backtester / demo trader, and have no idea what a live account looks like and how a lot of MT4 brokerages operate in terms of placing identifiable information in deposits and withdrawals. They don't do it to be malicious. They do it for accounting and compliance purposes.

Without any help from me, I think you just told on yourself because you obviously lack the knowledge in this department.

I won't be responding to any more of your posts so go wild! I simply do not have the time to defend against something that a) has nothing to do with the performance of this system b) just seems to be a debate for the purpose of debating and c) is terribly frustrating because the lack of knowledge on the other side of the argument is so lacking.

I did put my reason if you can read 'or may be some trades handled manually'

some trades could be handled manually or with some other EA s for saving the DD. if EA Logic failed ones it will do it again due to my experience.

but you will never proof that all trades has been handled by the EA itself without unlocking comments.

statarbpro posted:

stevewalker posted:
giving strategy with comments
giving bank information with comments

being funny with every post

go on

All that said, you have not explained WHY you want to see them so badly and what benefit that will give? Because you want to see them is not reason enough for me to divulge personal information for the world to see. Post your bank account numbers here. No? Well then me either!

hhoohhhh changing posts after 'adding new lines' shows that you are very angry. get another cup of coffee and cool down
I use card for my fund and withdrawls instead of direct wire transfer. from where I live it is cheaper.

I will be watching 297$ system that makes fortunes for hedge funds.

I am not selling anything so I dont need to publish any live account.

walker

statarbpro posted:

stevewalker posted:
giving strategy with comments
giving bank information with comments

being funny with every post

go on

All that said, you have not explained WHY you want to see them so badly and what benefit that will give? Because you want to see them is not reason enough for me to divulge personal information for the world to see. Post your bank account numbers here. No? Well then me either!

I'm pretty sure what is going on here is you're the quintessential backtester / demo trader, and have no idea what a live account looks like and how a lot of MT4 brokerages operate in terms of placing identifiable information in deposits and withdrawals. They don't do it to be malicious. They do it for accounting and compliance purposes.

Without any help from me, I think you just told on yourself because you obviously lack the knowledge in this department.

I won't be responding to any more of your posts so go wild! I simply do not have the time to defend against something that a) has nothing to do with the performance of this system b) just seems to be a debate for the purpose of debating and c) is terribly frustrating because the lack of knowledge on the other side of the argument is so lacking.

I see your point in one instance. In the event of a stoploss, the system would print [sl] right? and in the event of a takeprofit the EA would print [tp], right?

Statarb Pro manages the trades based on a floating profit or loss. 9e.g. if OrderProfit() <= RiskPerArb() || TotalRisk() the trade or all trades are closed.

There are no hard stops or takeprofits. Therefore, your argument in the case of this system is invalid. The answer is still no.

should never argue with idiots because they will just drag you down to their level....then beat you with experience !

11 years of experience is more then enough I guess

walker

'I won't be responding to any more of your posts so go wild!'

hold your word
walker

statarbpro posted:
I see your point in one instance. In the event of a stoploss, the system would print [sl] right? and in the event of a takeprofit the EA would print [tp], right?

Statarb Pro manages the trades based on a floating profit or loss. 9e.g. if OrderProfit() <= RiskPerArb() || TotalRisk() the trade or all trades are closed.

There are no hard stops or takeprofits. Therefore, your argument in the case of this system is invalid. The answer is still no.

stevewalker posted:
hhoohhhh changing posts after 'adding new lines' shows that you are very angry. get another cup of coffee and cool down
I use card for my fund and withdrawls instead of direct wire transfer. from where I live it is cheaper.

I added some lines to be more clear, yes. It didn't warrant a new post.

I am not selling anything so I dont need to publish any live account.

walker

Spoken like a man who doesn't have one. So, please post this mythical live account of yours. I'm dying to see it. Just like everyone else who posts nonsense in this thread I will tell you this:

Post your results so we can compare or, forever be relegated to the 'another guy talking smack' crowd who isn't able to provide a shred of evidence. My evidence is all out there for you to pick apart and criticize, but the results keep coming forward. You have 2 demo accounts and a lot of backtests.

Any further comments from you will be met with the response of 'show me your results. I show mine.'